Lessonpills
Sign up
Premium

The great debate: understanding the Oxford comma

This lesson explores the ongoing debate surrounding the Oxford comma, highlighting its importance for clarity and preventing ambiguity in English writing. It includes interactive exercises for listening, vocabulary, and grammar practice.

C1 Grammar Practical English Video
The great debate: understanding the Oxford comma

Summary

This ESL lesson for C1 English students delves into the long-standing Oxford comma debate, helping them understand its role in clarity and ambiguity within English grammar. Through an engaging video and interactive exercises, students will explore arguments for and against its use across different style guides.

The material is designed to foster critical thinking about punctuation choices and their impact on meaning, providing practical tools for advanced written communication. Activities include a warm-up discussion, video comprehension, vocabulary building, and targeted grammar practice focused on achieving sentence clarity.

Access lesson

Activities

  • A warm-up discussion where students share personal experiences with grammatical ambiguity and the importance of punctuation rules.
  • Listening comprehension with gap-fill exercises based on a video that humorously explains the Oxford comma and the differing views of major language institutions.
  • A vocabulary matching task introducing advanced terms from the video, such as multitalented, ill-fated, denote, cluttered, truce, and hairsplitting.
  • A grammar exercise focusing on the correct application of the Oxford comma to ensure clarity in various sentence structures.
  • A vocabulary in context activity to reinforce understanding and usage of new words.
  • A sentence clarity practice requiring students to rewrite sentences, adding the Oxford comma where necessary to avoid ambiguity.
  • Speaking practice encouraging students to discuss their preferred stylistic choices and the value of detailed grammatical debates.
00:00:7 Say you're helping plan a friend's party,
00:00:9 and he sends you a text
00:00:11 asking you to "bring Bob, a DJ and a clown."
00:00:14 You're pretty impressed.
00:00:15 You had no idea Bob was so multitalented.
00:00:17 But when the day arrives,
00:00:19 it turns out that he's not,
00:00:21 and you were supposed to bring three different people.
00:00:24 As you and Bob sit at the silent, clownless party,
00:00:27 it occurs to you that the confusion could've been avoided
00:00:30 simply by using another comma after DJ.
00:00:34 This final comma in a list,
00:00:35 placed directly before the main conjunction,
00:00:38 such as and, or, or nor,
00:00:41 is called the serial comma,
00:00:42 or Oxford comma.
00:00:44 And it has long driven grammar nerds crazy
00:00:47 because even major language institutions
00:00:49 can't agree on whether it should be used.
00:00:51 Ironically, the Oxford comma
00:00:53 is more common in the United States,
00:00:54 where it's recommended by
00:00:56 the MLA, the Chicago Style Manual,
00:00:58 and the US Government Printing Office,
00:01:0 though not by the AP Style Book.
00:01:2 In the UK and other English-speaking countries,
00:01:5 most style guides do not support the comma's use,
00:01:7 with the exception of its namesake,
00:01:9 the Oxford University Press.
00:01:11 Why not use the serial comma?
00:01:13 One of the main arguments
00:01:15 is that the conjunction is usually enough
00:01:16 to denote a separate entity.
00:01:18 And where it's not,
00:01:19 like in your ill-fated invite list,
00:01:21 changing the order of terms will usually do the job.
00:01:24 Journalists also dislike the comma
00:01:26 because it takes up precious space
00:01:28 and can make text look cluttered.
00:01:30 Sometimes, it can even create confusion of its own.
00:01:32 For example,
00:01:34 if your friend had asked for "Bob,
00:01:35 a DJ and a puppy,"
00:01:37 you'd probably figure out
00:01:38 that they're three separate beings.
00:01:40 Puppies are cute,
00:01:41 but they don't make great DJs.
00:01:42 With the comma,
00:01:44 you may think
00:01:45 Bob is the DJ,
00:01:46 and all you need is him and the puppy.
00:01:48 The argument over the Oxford comma
00:01:50 has raised such strong passions over the years
00:01:52 that a sort of truce has been reached.
00:01:56 The common wisdom is that
00:01:57 its use is optional,
00:01:58 and depends on whether it will help
00:02:0 to avoid confusion.
00:02:2 For one thing,
00:02:3 you're supposed to keep your use or avoidance
00:02:5 of the Oxford comma
00:02:7 consistent throughout a whole piece of writing.
00:02:9 So, using it only where necessary
00:02:10 is not an option.
00:02:12 And the very idea
00:02:13 of a grammatical rule being optional
00:02:15 is a bit odd.
00:02:17 Imagine that you hadn't messed up the party planning,
00:02:19 and read the next day that "everyone had a great time -
00:02:21 ninjas, pirates, vikings, old and young."
00:02:24 If the Oxford comma were standard,
00:02:26 you would notice it missing
00:02:28 and conclude that old and young
00:02:29 must describe the awesome guests already listed.
00:02:33 But as things stand,
00:02:34 you will always wonder
00:02:35 whether it means
00:02:36 that a bunch of regular, boring kids and old people
00:02:38 showed up as well.
00:02:40 Ultimately, the serial comma may be useful or annoying,
00:02:43 but your opinion on it,
00:02:44 as for many optional things,
00:02:46 probably has something to do
00:02:47 with whichever style you were raised on.
00:02:50 Your high school teachers favored it?
00:02:52 It's likely you're still using it.
00:02:54 Your first editor hated it?
00:02:55 You probably do, too.
00:02:57 And maybe so much hairsplitting
00:02:59 over a tiny squiggle on a page
00:03:1 is a bit silly.
00:03:2 After all,
00:03:3 there are so many bigger problems
00:03:4 to worry about.
00:03:5 But sometimes, little things can make a big difference.

Vocabulary focus

The vocabulary section introduces a range of terms critical for discussing nuanced linguistic debates and communication issues. Key terms include multitalented, ill-fated, denote, cluttered, truce, and hairsplitting. Students will practice using these words to articulate arguments and describe situations related to grammatical choices and their consequences.

Grammar focus

This lesson primarily focuses on the Oxford comma (also known as the serial comma). Students will learn to recognize situations where its inclusion is vital for preventing ambiguity and enhancing clarity in lists of three or more items, contrasting its use across different English-speaking regions and style guides. The grammar exercises aim to solidify understanding of its purpose in written communication.

Share Share Share Share Share Email

Related

Health science: Is exercise the best way to lose weight?
B2 Lifestyle Practical English General Grammar Psychology Video

Health science: Is exercise the best way to lose weight?

This lesson explores the scientific understanding that exercise alone is often ineffective for weight loss, emphasizing the primary role of diet and basal metabolism. It debunks common misconceptions about energy expenditure and introduces the concept of compensatory behaviors.

Premium
Culinary history: The global journey of dumplings
B2 Practical English Grammar Lifestyle Travel General Video

Culinary history: The global journey of dumplings

Explore the fascinating global history of dumplings, tracing their journey from ancient origins to diverse culinary adaptations worldwide. This lesson covers listening, vocabulary, and grammar focusing on the Past Simple Passive.

Premium
Sustainability: The high cost of fast fashion
B2 Practical English Business Lifestyle General Work Grammar Video

Sustainability: The high cost of fast fashion

This lesson explores the environmental and social impact of fast fashion. It delves into the concept of sustainability within the fashion industry and encourages discussion on consumer choices and corporate responsibilities.

Premium